Sinn Féin has positioned itself against parishioners of St Mary’s Catholic Church in Belfast city centre by indicating support for a late night entertainments licence for a new venue in a listed building right beside the chapel.
Elected representatives at Belfast City Council this week heard that the St Mary’s community was “hurt and upset” and no longer fully trusted the groups involved in bringing entertainment to the old Electric Light Station at 6 Chapel Lane and 9–13 Marquis Street.
At the monthly meeting of the Belfast City Council Licensing Committee last night an application by Bernard Lavery for a 14 day occasional indoor entertainments licence for Belfast Electric Light Station was deferred by elected representatives for further details and for a potential meeting between the applicant and objectors.
READ MORE: Plans for major Belfast visitor attraction reach ‘significant milestone’
READ MORE: Queen’s University plan to turn old creche into student house refused as HMO attempt
Built in 1895, the Electric Light Station was Belfast’s first municipal power station. It was bought by MRP Investment and Development Ltd two and a half years ago and this summer the Laverys, as “operating partners,” transformed the listed building into a venue for a comedy night, then Belfast Pride and Fleadh Cheoil na hÉireann.
St Mary’s Catholic Church is Belfast’s oldest surviving Catholic Church. Opening in 1784. The Electric Light Station lies between St Mary’s Church and Ladbrokes/Sloans Gym. The chapel shares an entire wall with the Electric Light Station, with a prayer room, a confessional, a sacristy, a radio station and a community hall all adjoining the new venue.
A council report on the application states: “The objectors did not wish to attend a facilitated meeting with the applicant and subsequently reaffirmed their intention to make representation to the committee, with one collective representation to be made on behalf of St Mary’s Parish.”
Father Bartlett, the parish priest at St Mary’s Church, told the Licensing Committee on Wednesday evening: “This is a very sincere, anxious and heartfelt appeal, for your understanding, your support and your commitment to the rights and freedoms of the citizens of Belfast of all backgrounds who use and value the faith, properties and heritage of their city.
“The proposed use of this historic electricity station on Chapel Lane is precisely what our community feared most when the building went up for sale. We seriously never imagined anyone would propose a daytime to late night entertainment venue immediately adjoining an active church. And to advertise events that in their own words move from “daytime euphoria” to “late night madness”.
“A church, a mosque, a synagogue or a temple is not simply another building in a city centre commercial environment. Such places are fundamental to the heritage and life of their communities. They also, I would argue strongly, engage in a fundamental human right, that is, freedom of religion and worship.”
He added: “An entertainment licence, however welcome and appropriate at times, is not a human right.” He said the right to religious worship was one his “parishioners would be determined to defend through the courts if necessary”.
“There was no consultation with the parish before events in the summer were advertised, tickets were sold and substantial investment made in the venue. Indeed we cooperated as good neighbours in facilitating some of the works, without knowing their intended purpose.
“The Fleadh was an exceptional occasion and we supported it. I acknowledge that the venue was well managed by the applicants during that time. We were told however that the events permitted there, of an entertainment nature, did not require a licence, as they were busking style events and unamplified.
“If that is all that is intended, why are we here today? The venue is currently advertised, on their website right now, as opening from noon until 1am seven days a week. Every Sunday at 11.30am, St Mary’s celebrates the longest running Irish language mass on this island. Where is the sensitivity to that, and where is the consultation?”
Regarding the proximity of other bars in the area, he said: “We get a little feed-in from Kelly’s from time to time, but we work very closely with them, and if there is any difficulty we will generally tell them and we will collaborate. That hasn’t always worked well, but it is a reality, they have been there as long as we have. Do we need another case? No in my opinion, and that of my parishioners. We accept Kelly’s and Maddens are there.”
A parishioner and objector appearing with Father Bartlett at the committee said: “I cannot overstate how hurt and upset the wider community at St Mary’s were over what happened during the summer. No one had any idea until it started popping up on Instagram, tickets were sold and no one said anything to us.” She said parishioners’ trust was “damaged.”
DUP Councillor Tracy Kelly said at the meeting: “What is most striking to me is that it is a place of worship, and it should be safe. There is residential space there for priests, and community space, which is being used a lot of the time for very positive things.” She said she had “definite concerns” about the impact on Sunday services, and said it would be ‘a bit unfair’.”
TUV Councillor Ron McDowell said: “Last orders would be 1am and you would imagine people would be piling out onto the street at about 2 or 3 o’clock in the morning. That gives the council only about five hours to do the road sweep and bring the area back into some sort of normality, where parishioners are not arriving and walking over broken glass. I would see a bit of difficulty in that.”
Sinn Féin Councillor Pádraig Donnelly said: “It just seems that there is roadblock upon roadblock from one side here. We are here to represent everyone, and that includes our secular society.
“We have to remember that the vast majority of Belfast, as per the census, are not attending churches. We have to balance this.”
A representative for MRP told the committee they invested “several hundred thousand” into the building for the Fleadh and “didn’t come close to getting it back in terms of reinvestment.” He said: “Our business model centres around a creative hospitality space that attracts discerning clientele, supports local artists, musicians and staff, and brings positive footfall to a part of the city that desperately needs investment.”
Bernard Lavery told the committee: “My family has been operating licensed premises for over 100 years, and you don’t do that without being good neighbours. And that is exactly what we would propose here, to be a good neighbour.
“On several occasions I met with Father Tim and we tried to find some common ground and that became difficult towards the end. I appreciate the fact they allowed us to continue during the Fleadh, which was wonderful for the Electric Light Station, the Fleadh, and Belfast in general.
“Nothing we would do there would be done without the consent and hopefully the approval of St Mary’s Church. It is vitally important that whatever goes on there is done hand in glove with our neighbours.” He said sound reports would have to be conducted for impacts on the church and apartments.
DUP Councillor Ruth Brooks proposed deferring the decision until the December meeting of the Licensing Committee for both the applicant and objectors “to sit down and have a conversation.”
Sinn Féin Councillor Conor McKay said he was “uncomfortable” to defer without assurances both parties would meet, and then proposed the committee approve the entertainment licence with conditions, including consultation with parishioners, and sound proofing. The committee Chair, Alliance Councillor Tara Brooks, proposed granting the licence with the two Sundays of Fleadh 2027 being the only Sundays permitted.
Both of these proposals were dropped, and all elected representatives agreed to defer the matter to a “special meeting.”
For all the latest news, visit the Belfast Live homepage here and sign up to our daily newsletter here.


