A public register had details taken off after the summer race riots
Questions have been raised at Belfast City Hall around transparency of information of HMOs.
Before the summer race riots in Belfast and elsewhere, and dating back to the days when the Housing Executive controlled HMOs, there has been a publicly available list of registered HMOs to allow tenants to make an informed decision on accommodation they were considering to rent. Councils took over the running of HMOs in April 2019, with central control emanating from Belfast City Hall.
At the Belfast City Council monthly meeting of its Licensing Committee, up until the summer, HMO licenses issued under delegated authority had details open to the public. Since the riots, newly issued and renewed licences are held in secret “restricted” sessions away from public and press at City Hall, while the public online register was closed for all 11 councils.
READ MORE: Queen’s University plan to turn old creche into student house refused as HMO attempt
READ MORE: Plans for major Belfast visitor attraction reach ‘significant milestone’
Houses of Multiple Occupation, also known as a “house-share” residencies, which landlords lease out to three or more tenants from different addresses, have become increasingly controversial, with some arguing they have negatively affected communities and led to anti-social behaviour in places like the Holylands and Stranmillis in South Belfast, where landlords pack houses with undergraduates, young professionals and others.
Council officers at Belfast City Hall continue to argue that while overprovision is a problem in areas in the city, HMOs remain an essential mode of housing. Meanwhile some local politicians are airing concerns that HMOs are becoming conflated with immigration levels, amidst a rising tide of racist debate on social media.
The HMO debate became even more complex during the race riots in the summer this year after anti-immigration agitators used public registries of HMO properties to compile and circulate “hit lists” of addresses believed to house migrants and asylum seekers. Official figures show that less than 10 percent of all HMOs in Northern Ireland house refugees, and the vast majority of HMO residents are born in Northern Ireland.
At the meeting of the Belfast City Council Licensing Committee on Wednesday (November 18) DUP Councillor Ruth Brooks criticised the new move to restricted sessions for issued HMO licences at City Hall. She said: “My concern with having an entire paper restricted is that there is no information now going out to people. I don’t know what will come forward when decisions are made in terms of the council, if addresses will be published.
“I think we still need a level of transparency in terms of the number of HMOs that have been put in for application, approved, or have been renewed or rejected.”
A council officer said: “This is a delegated authority report that we have had since the introduction of the scheme. At the June meeting a decision was taken, based on legal advice, that the delegated authority report would be restricted.
“The report is restricted pursuant to section 6.13 of the Local Government Act, in that the information relates to the financial or business affairs of any particular person.”
Green Party Councillor Brian Smyth said at the meeting: “We have had three consecutive years of racial violence in this city. Ethnic minorities are being targeted. HMOs are a new battlefront. We have online racist agitators using HMOs to stoke tensions here.
“We have seen in the information of HMOs by ward that 86 percent of HMOs across the city are in three wards, Windsor, Central, and Stranmillis. Many of them are students.
“There is a lot of misinformation, disinformation, and downright lies about HMOs at the minute. They are symptoms of a wider housing failure.”
Councillor Smyth said HMOs were “taking properties off the market for families and young people” and said there was a problem of “rampant landlordism.”
He added: “I have issues with HMOs, but I believe online racist scumbags are using them to take on a new front. We need to be careful how we approach this. I am all for transparency, but I also know that HMO lists have been put up online during racial violence this summer, and previously, houses have been attacked.
“Under 10 percent of HMO houses are occupied by refugees. Personally it wouldn’t bother me what percentage is occupied by refugees, but there are a lot of lies out there.
“If you want to dig into the issues of HMOs, it is a failure of provision. The current Minister (who covers housing) is a DUP Minister. We have only built 19,000 social homes since the signing of the Good Friday Agreement, when we should have built 40,000. That is a failure of the Stormont Executive.”
The public online HMO register gave the names of applicants and agents, licence holders, property addresses, permitted occupancy, and the start and expiry dates of the licence. There is no statutory requirement for an online public register.
The online consultation register, a separate register, relates to property owners wanting to get a HMO licence for their property. They are required to publish notice of the application in a newspaper circulating in the locality of the HMO and the applicant must supply a copy of that advert to the council.
HMO officials at City Hall learned that several HMO properties had been targeted as part of the unrest in June and took what they described as “precautionary measures” to remove from the website those publicly available entries from the HMO register, as well as the online application consultation register.
PSNI described as “totally unacceptable” a list of HMO addresses being circulated on social media, where it was claimed that immigrants were living. They said anyone sharing the list “may be committing a criminal offence.”
After the riots the Home Office and representatives of Mears Housing, the appointed Home Office asylum accommodation provider, contacted the NIHMO Service requesting that it suspend access to the HMO register on the grounds that the information was being used to target migrant and asylum seekers.
The Landlords Association for Northern Ireland contacted the NIHMO Service to confirm the targeting, while individual HMO owners and managing agents requested their online entries on the HMO register not be reinstated.
At the latest count, Northern Ireland has 3647 HMO registered properties. Belfast Council has the vast majority of them at 3020, next Derry City and Strabane at 261, then Causeway Coast and Glens at 214.
Antrim and Newtownabbey Council has 15, Ards and North Down Council has 13, Armagh City Banbridge and Craigavon Council has 59, while Fermanagh and Omagh Council has 5. Lisburn and Castlereagh Council has 8, Mid and East Antrim 13, Mid Ulster 21, Newry Mourne and Down Council has 18.
Of all the 33 Belfast wards, three hold the vast majority of HMOs, Central with 1389, Windsor with 951, and Stranmillis with 270.
For all the latest news, visit the Belfast Live homepage here and sign up to our daily newsletter here.



