Committee Chair says: “We might see more of these applications coming forward, as a way of trying to circumvent HMO requirements and thresholds.”
A planning application by Queen’s University Belfast to turn an old creche and nursery into a small student block has been refused, after councillors said it appeared to be an attempt to create a HMO building by another name.
At the November meeting of the Belfast City Council Planning Committee, held this week at City Hall, elected representatives overwhelmingly voted against an application for the change of use from a creche and day care nursery to purpose built managed student accommodation, at Rugby Road, just beside the Holylands in South Belfast. The application by Queens included nine single rooms and two twin rooms.
Council planning officers recommended approval for the application, and stated in a report: “Due regard is had (about) QUB as the applicant, the small scale nature of the proposal, its accessible location and the ability to effectively manage the proposal through a legal agreement. The principle of the proposed use is considered acceptable.”
READ MORE: ‘Get in earlier next time’: New Christmas market warned as it gets the OK
Belfast Council received 37 objections to the application, and NI Water recommended the plan be refused. The council’s own development plan housing team also objected.
Third party objectors raised concerns about the impact on the residential amenity and referred to HMO Policy, stating that the area had 30 percent HMO housing, well above the 20 percent maximum stipulated by policy for a Housing Management Area, which Rugby Road falls under. They said Rugby Road should be preserved for family homes, and added the student accommodation market was “now satisfied” and had “no demand.”
Objectors also expressed concern about the impact on parking and waste water infrastructure, and some said there were inappropriate bin storage plans. Some said the proposal would interfere with the running of a nearby mosque, and one objector referred to an agreement with planning that QUB would “not develop this side of the university.”
Council Planning officers said in the application report: “Following legal advice the proposal is considered purpose built student accommodation and therefore HMO policy does not apply.”
They said: “A parking survey was submitted and DFI Roads had no objections with conditions. A solution has been identified and is deliverable through the completion of stage two of the Waste Water Impact Assessment. The council have been instructed that payment has been issued to NI Water and a re-consultation has been issued.”
They added: “Sufficient bin storage has been provided with the proposal. There is no evidence the proposal will impact places of worship that surround the application site.”
Regarding the assertion there was an agreement with planning that QUB would not develop this side of the university, the case officer responded: “There is no such agreement and each application is determined on its own merits.”
They added: “Policy only protects those in current use as residential, in this case the previous use was a creche. It is recognised there is likely no further demand for purpose built managed student accommodation development, however this is a small scale scheme in which Queens University are the applicant and therefore the provision of 11 further rooms is unlikely to impact the existing student accommodation.”
Sinn Féin Councillor Natasha Brennan proposed refusal for the application at the Planning Committee meeting on Tuesday (November 17). She said: “Because we are classing it as purpose built managed student accommodation, the HMO policy doesn’t apply. But I think when you look at this in the wider context of the area, HMO policy should apply.
“These are individual rooms, they are not individual apartments, so technically this is a HMO. That would be my reading of it.”
Green Party Councillor Áine Groogan said: “This application falls between a number of different policies, and what we have doesn’t adequately cover it. Yes it falls out of HMO policy under the definition that it is managed by an educational organisation, but it doesn’t fit our policy around purpose built managed student accommodation either. Because firstly it isn’t purpose built, and secondly it isn’t above 200 units. We can’t ignore the fact it is in a Housing Management Area, and it is in a residential area.”
She added: “I do fear this is a bit of a workaround because we know no more HMOs should get past, given the policy in place. Maybe that is being cynical, but it does feel that way.”
Planning Committee Chair, Sinn Féin Councillor Ryan Murphy said: “I would be worried if we were to go down this road (and approve), that looking at other further education centres around town, we might see more of these applications coming forward, as a way of trying to circumvent the HMO requirements and thresholds.”
The Sinn Féin proposal to refuse the application went to a vote. 15 voted in favour of the proposal and one voted against the proposal, SDLP Councillor Carl Whyte. Officers were given “delegated authority” to word the reasons for refusal.
For all the latest news, visit the Belfast Live homepage here and sign up to our daily newsletter here.



