In March, Brighton and Hove City Council published an independent report from the Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy on lessons learnt from the original decision to extend a loan to the i360.
The report stated visitor numbers were significantly overestimated and that “optimism bias” was evident throughout the business plan.
In a special audit, standards and general purposes committee on November 24, the report is set to be discussed.
(Image: Newsquest)
Labour councillors said they will “demand answers about the failures” and seek assurances the council has safeguards in place to prevent it happening again.
Labour member of the Audit, Standards and General Purposes Committee Councillor Josh Guilmant said: “What happened with the i360 wasn’t simply bad luck. It was a catastrophic financial decision from the Green Party, which Labour councillors warned against at the time.
“The independent report identifies some really serious problems with the assumptions, financial modelling, risk management and governance behind the original decision.”
The report confirmed what The Argus revealed in 2022 when the business case that helped convince politicians to approve a £36 million taxpayer-backed loan to build the i360 was accidentally handed to The Argus by council officials.
The Greens criticised the report stating it was “factually inaccurate” and a “complete waste of money”.
The report was due to be discussed on April 21, however Councillor Pete West said that he did not consider the report to be complete and would not accept it on the committee’s agenda on April 21.
Further emails accused Councillor West of attempting to “block” the report due to the fact it “might be embarrassing to his own political record”.
Rh Cllr Pete West
The original plans for the i360 were submitted by husband-and-wife architects David Marks and Julia Barfield in 2006.
It opened in August 2016 after the loan was agreed by the city council under a minority Green Party administration led by Jason Kitcat.
The initial plan for the i360 was for it to be privately financed, but when no buyer came forward, the Greens were asked to speculatively back the project with £36 million of public money via a loan from the public works board. The council would be responsible for paying it back after being reimbursed by the i360 company.
Labour councillors originally supported the i360, but in 2014 former leader, Warren Morgan gave a speech opposing the loan, arguing it was a high-risk financial commitment for the council.
Labour councillors voted against the public loan and the project was pushed through by a combination of Green and Conservative votes.
Prior to local elections in May 2023, Labour councillors began to brand the i360 a “Green/Tory vanity project”.
In December 2024, the attraction entered administration and closed. It was later bought by former Dragon’s Den entrepreneur Sarah Willingham and her company, Nightcap.
Source link
[Featured]
[Just In]


